When diving into the world of luxury automobiles, the debate between Mercedes-Benz and Lexus often surfaces, especially when considering models from the late 20th century. For enthusiasts looking at classic examples, the Mercedes-Benz W124 and the Lexus LS 400 (also known as the Toyota Celsior in some markets) present an interesting contrast. Both represent different philosophies in automotive engineering and luxury. This comparison aims to highlight the strengths and weaknesses of each, helping you understand which might be a better fit based on your priorities.
Reliability and Maintenance: The Pragmatic Choice
One of the most significant factors for any car owner, particularly with older vehicles, is reliability and the potential for maintenance. Here, Lexus generally takes the lead. Owners often report fewer problems with the Lexus LS 400 compared to the Mercedes W124, especially concerning electrical systems. While the interior materials of the W124 are often praised for their robust quality and a more premium feel, the Lexus tends to hold up better in terms of mechanical and electrical longevity. It’s not uncommon to see Lexus models with high mileage still running smoothly, whereas some Mercedes from the same era might face issues like biodegradable wiring harnesses. This difference in long-term reliability can translate to fewer unexpected repairs and potentially lower running costs for the Lexus owner in the long run.
Interior Comfort and Features: A Tale of Two Approaches
Stepping inside both cars reveals distinct approaches to luxury and comfort. The Lexus LS 400 prioritizes convenience and a plush, comfortable experience. It typically comes equipped with a wider array of “creature comforts” and thoughtful ergonomic details. Features like power-adjustable, softer seats, a lighter accelerator pedal, and superior instrument illumination make the Lexus a more relaxed and comfortable car, especially in modern traffic conditions. In contrast, the W124, while offering quality, can feel somewhat more basic in terms of features. For instance, the original author noted the surprise of a telescoping but non-tilting steering wheel in the Mercedes, a feature commonly found in Lexus models of the same era. Furthermore, the Lexus often boasts a better-integrated and higher-quality sound system than its Mercedes counterpart.
Driving Experience and Design: Old School Charm vs. Modern Refinement
The driving experience and design philosophy further differentiate these two vehicles. The Mercedes W124 embodies a more “old school” approach to automotive engineering. This results in a car with a stronger sense of personality and a more direct, albeit sometimes less refined, driving feel. The Lexus LS 400, on the other hand, emphasizes smoothness and refinement in every aspect, from its incredibly smooth transmission to its focus on Noise, Vibration, and Harshness (NVH) reduction. While the Lexus provides a supremely comfortable and quiet ride, some might find it lacking in character. The design of the LS 400, often perceived as generic or overly conservative, contrasts with the more distinctive and arguably more timeless aesthetics of the W124. Many argue that the W124’s design has aged more gracefully and retains a classic appeal that the LS 400, with its resemblance to a larger Toyota Camry, sometimes lacks.
Conclusion: Choosing Your Ideal Classic Luxury Car
In conclusion, the choice between a Mercedes W124 and a Lexus LS 400 depends heavily on individual priorities. If reliability, ease of maintenance, and a focus on comfort and modern conveniences are paramount, the Lexus LS 400 is arguably the stronger choice. Its reputation for durability and its array of comfort features make it a practical and relaxing classic luxury car. However, if interior material quality, a more engaging “old school” driving experience, and a timeless, distinctive design are more appealing, the Mercedes-Benz W124 offers a compelling alternative. It presents a more characterful and arguably more prestigious option, despite potentially requiring more attention to maintenance over time. Ultimately, both cars offer unique strengths, and understanding these differences is key to making an informed decision.
