Mercedes-Benz R-Class: An Underrated SUV or Super Wagon? – Owner’s Review

Having transitioned from a 2004 Toyota Sienna LE to a 2010 R350BT, it’s clear these aren’t directly comparable vehicles. The Sienna is undeniably a minivan, while the R-Class, in my opinion, leans more towards a generously sized station wagon, albeit one with an extra row of seats tucked in the back. Driving the Sienna was a breeze – light steering, smooth ride, and surprising acceleration when needed. Now, focusing on the Mercedes SUV R-Class, here’s a breakdown of the pros and cons based on my experience.

Pros of the Mercedes-Benz R-Class

1. Exceptional Value for Money: You get a significant amount of car for what you pay. The R-Class represents a compelling deal in the used car market, offering luxury and space at a reasonable price point.

2. Powerful Diesel Engine: The diesel engine, particularly in models like the R350BT, provides ample power for highway driving and overtaking, even when the vehicle is fully loaded with passengers and cargo. It offers a confident and responsive driving experience.

3. Spacious Interior: The R-Class excels in interior space. It comfortably accommodates passengers and offers versatile cargo configurations, making it ideal for families or anyone needing extra room.

4. Exclusivity and Rarity: The Mercedes SUV R-Class is not a common sight on the roads. Owning one offers a degree of exclusivity and sets you apart from the more ubiquitous SUV models. Its unique design ensures it stands out.

5. Attractive Aesthetics: Despite its size, the R-Class boasts a good-looking design. It manages to be both substantial and stylish, offering a premium appearance that aligns with the Mercedes-Benz brand.

6. Car Wash Value: Its sheer size means you definitely get your money’s worth at the car wash! The expansive exterior ensures a thorough clean and makes the most of your car washing investment.

7. Respectable Fuel Economy: Especially the diesel models achieve commendable gas mileage. My R-Class diesel performs similarly in fuel consumption to my previous Toyota Sienna, which is impressive for a vehicle of its size and class.

8. Standard Rear Auto-Leveling Suspension: The inclusion of standard rear auto-leveling suspension enhances ride comfort and stability, especially when carrying loads or towing. This feature contributes to a smoother and more controlled driving experience.

9. Built-in Beer Bottle Opener: A quirky but appreciated standard feature – an industry-leading beer bottle opener integrated into the R-Class. A testament to Mercedes-Benz’s attention to detail and perhaps a bit of fun.

Cons of the Mercedes-Benz R-Class

1. AdBlue Requirement (Diesel Models from MY2009): Diesel models from model year 2009 onwards require AdBlue, a diesel exhaust fluid. This adds a minor inconvenience and cost to maintenance, requiring periodic refills.

2. Limited Trunk Space: With all seats in use, the trunk space is undeniably small. This can be a limitation for larger families or those needing to carry significant cargo regularly.

3. Run-Flat Tires (RFT) on MY2009 Diesel Models: The 2009 diesel models often come with run-flat tires (RFT). While offering puncture protection, RFTs can compromise ride comfort and are more expensive to replace. This can be addressed by switching to regular tires and carrying a tire repair kit (TIREFIT).

Minor Drawbacks

4. Pano-roof Shade Operation: The shades for the panoramic roof lack a one-touch closing feature, a minor inconvenience compared to more modern systems.

5. Parktronic System Speed: The Parktronic parking assist system can be a bit slow to react, requiring a bit of patience when maneuvering in tight spaces.

6. AdBlue Swishing Noise: In diesel models, a half-empty AdBlue tank can sometimes produce a noticeable swishing noise, which might be slightly bothersome to some owners.

7. Slower Acceleration in C Mode: In “Comfort” (C) mode, acceleration can feel somewhat sluggish. Switching to “Sport” (S) mode improves responsiveness but may affect fuel economy.

8. Non-Flat Folding Seats: The rear seats do not fold completely flat, which slightly limits the versatility of the cargo area when maximizing space.

9. High Trunk Floor: The trunk floor is positioned quite high, which can make loading and unloading heavier items a bit more challenging.

10. HID Headlights as DRL in Canadian Models: For Canadian models, the High-Intensity Discharge (HID) headlights function as Daytime Running Lights (DRL), which some owners may find unnecessary and potentially reducing bulb lifespan.

Conclusion: Is the Mercedes-Benz R-Class Right for You?

Ultimately, the best way to determine if the Mercedes SUV R-Class is the right vehicle for you is to take one for a test drive. Experiencing the R-Class firsthand will answer any lingering questions and doubts. The R-Class remains one of the most understated Mercedes-Benz models available. Its greatness is truly appreciated by those who have driven and owned one. If you prioritize space, value, and a unique vehicle with a touch of luxury, the Mercedes R-Class is definitely worth considering.

Happy car shopping! And remember to share pictures of your new car if you decide to join the R-Class owners club!